If you're a fan of maple syrup (and we certainly are around here), you've probably wondered: Can I swap honey for maple syrup in my favorite recipes without losing sweetness? The short answer? Yes — but a few smart adjustments can make your swap seamless and delicious.
Whether you're cooking, baking, or whipping up brunch, here's everything you need to know.
🥄 Why Swap Honey for Maple Syrup?
There are a few great reasons to make the switch:
-
You're avoiding honey for dietary or taste reasons.
-
You want that warm, nostalgic maple flavor.
-
You just love a good drizzle of golden sweetness (we feel you).
But before you pour freely, let’s break down what makes honey and maple syrup different — and how to keep your recipe balanced.
📐 Basic Conversion: Honey to Maple Syrup
Start with a 1:1 ratio — if your recipe calls for 1 cup of honey, use 1 cup of maple syrup.
But honey is slightly sweeter and thicker than maple syrup, so you may need to tweak things depending on what you’re making.
🍞 In Baked Goods: Adjust Like a Pro
Maple syrup contains more water than honey and is a touch less sweet. If you’re baking cookies, muffins, or cakes:
-
Reduce liquid elsewhere in the recipe by about 1/4 cup per cup of maple syrup.
-
Boost sweetness slightly by adding 1–2 tablespoons of brown sugar if needed.
-
If your recipe uses baking soda, add a small acid like 1/4 teaspoon lemon juice or vinegar to help your treat rise properly (since maple is less acidic than honey).
🍳 What About French Toast?
Great news: no adjustment needed!
French toast custard is already liquid and designed to soak into the bread. If your recipe includes honey in the soak, just use an equal amount of maple syrup — no changes required.
That’s right:
-
No reducing milk or eggs
-
No adjusting sweetness
-
Just swap and go
Bonus? Your French toast will come out with a warm, subtly sweet maple flavor that turns breakfast into a cozy, campfire-worthy memory.
🛠 Quick Tip for Flavor
If you're swapping in real maple syrup, use Grade A Amber or Dark for richer flavor. These work beautifully in everything from glazes to marinades to morning waffles.
🍁 Final Thought
Honey and maple syrup each bring something special to the table, but don’t be afraid to go full maple. With a few thoughtful tweaks, you’ll keep the sweetness, preserve the texture — and maybe even fall in love with your recipe all over again.
Whether you’re baking, brunching, or building the best dang waffle stack this side of the Mississippi, maple’s got your back.
Want more cozy kitchen tips and maple inspiration?
Sign up for the Wild West Waffles roundup and ride into flavor town with us every week.